Can Pakistan's Small Nuclear Arsenal Survive India's First Strike?

Possession of nuclear weapons is considered "the ultimate deterrent" by eminent international geopolitical analysts like Professor John Mearsheimer of Chicago University. However, it appears that Mearsheimer has also raised questions about the survivability of a small land-based nuclear arsenal in the event of a first strike by a nuclear-armed adversary. Is this likely to tempt India to launch first strike against Pakistan's nuclear assets?

Pakistan's Nuclear Triad


In Mearsheimer's broader deterrence framework, small, land-based nuclear forces are inherently vulnerable to a disarming conventional or nuclear first strike. Because Pakistan’s arsenal is primarily land-based (alongside air-delivered systems), a major Indian military breakthrough or precision strike campaign could threaten the survivability of those weapons. This creates dangerous pressure on Islamabad to deploy or use its nuclear weapons early in a crisis rather than risk losing them. 

Pakistan's worries are reinforced by a Stimson Center poll that vast majority of Indians, including those who oppose Prime Minister Narendra Modi, believe that nuclear war is "winnable".  The respondents want their country to build a bigger nuclear arsenal than China and Pakistan combined.  Responding to the clamor for more nukes,  Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi said in 2019 that Indian nuclear weapons were not kept as mere showpieces.  Strong belief about India's ability to win a nuclear war against Pakistan cuts across party lines with 91% of those who support Mr. Modi and 85% of those who don't.  

These fears about the possibility of Indian first strike have forced Pakistan to build a full-spectrum deterrence, including a "nuclear triad" with air and sea-based launch capability to retaliate against India's first strike. Much of Pakistan's nuclear force utilizes mobile launchers (such as the Shaheen and Ghauri series) that can disperse and hide across varied terrain during a crisis, complicating an adversary's targeting. Pakistan has also constructed deeply buried and hardened underground storage and launch facilities to protect warheads and command structures from a disabling attack. 

By having a survivable nuclear deterrent, Pakistan can drastically reduce the likelihood of major war with India because the cost of mutual destruction would be too high. A region such as South Asia where both states have a survivable deterrent would be stable.

Related Links:

Haq's Musings

South Asia Investor Review

US Missile Sanctions: Is Pakistan Really Developing ICBMs?

Pakistan's Cyber Attack and Defense Capability

Pakistan Bolsters its Conventional Deterrence Against India

Pakistan's Rising Arms Sales

Pakistan Navy Modernization

Drone Swarms: Saudi Oil Fields Attack Shows Destructive Power

Pakistan Defense Industry

Silicon Valley Book Launch of "Eating Grass"

Pakistan's Modern Drone Fleet

Pakistan Destroyed Indian Rafales, S-400 Air Defense System

Pakistan's Sea-Based Second Strike Capability

Riaz Haq Youtube Channel

PakAlumi: Pakistani Social Network

Views: 65

Comment by Riaz Haq on Saturday

On October 26, 2006, a Chinese People's Liberation Army Navy (PLAN) Song-class (Type 039, same as Pakistan’s Hangor Class AIP-equipped) diesel-electric attack submarine surfaced undetected within five nautical miles of the aircraft carrier USS Kitty Hawk (CV-63) while it was operating with its strike group east of Okinawa, Japan. [1, 2, 3]
Key Details of the Incident
The Stalking and Surface: The Chinese submarine shadowed the U.S. carrier battle group—which included a dozen surface combatants, an attack submarine, and anti-submarine helicopters—without being detected by the fleet's defensive screen. It then surfaced within torpedo range (inside 5 miles) before being spotted visually by a routine aircraft surveillance flight. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Why it wasn't detected: The Song-class is a diesel-electric submarine that runs on quiet battery power during slow operations, producing very low acoustic signatures compared to nuclear-powered submarines that U.S. anti-submarine warfare (ASW) systems were primarily tuned to find. [1, 2]
Strategic Impact: Viewed as a watershed moment for China's naval modernization, the event shocked U.S. military planners and demonstrated the growing capability of non-nuclear submarines to challenge surface action groups in the Western Pacific. [1, 2]

—————

Pakistan’s Hangor-class submarine is an export variant based on China’s Type 039 (specifically the Type 039A/B or Yuan-class/S26 design). [1, 2, 3]
Key Details:
Base Design: It is developed by China Shipbuilding Industry Corporation (CSIC) as a derivative of the Chinese Type 039B / Yuan-class diesel-electric attack submarine. [1, 2]
Propulsion: It features a Stirling-cycle Air-Independent Propulsion (AIP) system, allowing it to stay submerged for much longer periods than traditional diesel-electric boats. [1, 2]
Production Program ("4+4" Model):
The first four submarines are built in China.
The remaining four are built locally in Pakistan at the Karachi Shipyard & Engineering Works (KSEW) via a technology transfer agreement. [1, 2]
Lead Vessel: The first-in-class boat, PNS Hangor, was commissioned in April 2026 and arrived in Pakistan later that summer. [1, 2

Comment by Riaz Haq 2 hours ago

U.S. Enters Unprecedented Three-Way Nuclear Rivalry With China and Russia
Beijing’s rapid weapons buildup forces Washington for the first time to prepare to face two major nuclear powers

https://www.wsj.com/world/u-s-enters-unprecedented-three-way-nuclea...

Some arms-control experts call this dynamic a “three-body problem”—a reference to the intractable physics puzzle in which three celestial bodies exert force on one another, making their movements deeply unpredictable.

------------

Not far from the bamboo-carpeted mountains of Sichuan province where giant pandas roam, a new uranium enrichment plant is nearing completion. Some researchers in the U.S. believe it is likely to be used to make fissile material for nuclear weapons, ending China’s four-decade pause on such production.

These recent findings show one of America’s biggest national-security challenges: China is rapidly building up its nuclear forces, opening the door to an unprecedented era of instability around the world’s most dangerous weapons.

Over the decades, American policymakers built and refined a nuclear deterrence strategy to counter one primary adversary, Russia. For the first time since the dawn of the atomic age, the U.S. must prepare to face two major rival powers with substantial nuclear capabilities.

Some arms-control experts call this dynamic a “three-body problem”—a reference to the intractable physics puzzle in which three celestial bodies exert force on one another, making their movements deeply unpredictable.

A new period of uncertainty and distrust risks reigniting the nuclear arms race.

President Trump will sit down with Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin this week for a three-way summit in which he plans to discuss nuclear-arms control. Trump will meet one-on-one with Putin on Thursday, a U.S. official said, although a Kremlin spokesman said no full-scale meeting was planned.

Beijing has repeatedly refused to participate in negotiations that could limit the size of its nuclear arsenal, noting that it has far fewer weapons than the U.S.

China’s arsenal has grown from the low 200s to around 600 nuclear warheads since the start of the decade. Though it remains much smaller than U.S. and Russian stockpiles, the rapid buildup has alarmed U.S. officials, many of whom believe America’s current nuclear strategy and force structure are insufficient to deal with this shifting landscape. The Pentagon projects that China is on track to have more than 1,000 nuclear warheads by 2030.

China’s Foreign Ministry said the country “always keeps its nuclear capabilities at the minimum level required for national security and has no intention of engaging in a nuclear arms race with any country.”

A senior U.S. official said ahead of Thursday’s summit that Washington recognizes the difficulty China faces in discussing nuclear arms control but believes Beijing must nevertheless engage in serious talks.

Meanwhile, the treaty between the U.S. and Russia that long set limits on their stockpiles expired in February. It is the first time in half a century that their long-range nuclear arms have been unconstrained by a legally binding agreement.

“We’re on the precipice of what is looking like an action-reaction-driven arms race because of this tripolar nuclear environment,” said Paul Dean, vice president of the nuclear policy program at the Nuclear Threat Initiative, a Washington-based nonprofit. It is occurring “at the exact same time that the tools that we have previously negotiated to stabilize and reduce risk of miscalculation have fallen away.”

The dynamic that long existed between the U.S. and Russia was relatively simple to understand. Each side built nuclear forces capable of surviving a first strike and launching a retaliation. The prospect of mutually assured destruction kept the “two-body” system stable.

Comment

You need to be a member of PakAlumni Worldwide: The Global Social Network to add comments!

Join PakAlumni Worldwide: The Global Social Network

Pre-Paid Legal


Twitter Feed

    follow me on Twitter

    Sponsored Links

    South Asia Investor Review
    Investor Information Blog

    Haq's Musings
    Riaz Haq's Current Affairs Blog

    Please Bookmark This Page!




    Blog Posts

    Can Pakistan's Small Nuclear Arsenal Survive India's First Strike?

    Possession of nuclear weapons is considered "the ultimate deterrent" by eminent international geopolitical analysts like Professor John Mearsheimer of Chicago University. However, it appears that Mearsheimer has also raised questions about the survivability of a small land-based nuclear arsenal in the event of a first strike by a nuclear-armed adversary. Is this likely to tempt India to launch first strike against Pakistan's nuclear assets?…

    Continue

    Posted by Riaz Haq on November 13, 2026 at 5:00pm — 2 Comments

    How Significant is Pakistan's Fa'az Air-to-Air Missile Flight Test?

    Pakistan's recent successful flight test of Fa'az, its indigenous air-to-air missile, has garnered significant international attention. What is its significance?  First, it is a major breakthrough for its national defense industry, elevating Pakistan into an elite, relatively small group of nations possessing the complex engineering expertise required to build weapons capable of hunting fighter jets. Second, it enhances the country's self-reliance and makes it less vulnerable…

    Continue

    Posted by Riaz Haq on November 6, 2026 at 10:30am — 5 Comments

    © 2026   Created by Riaz Haq.   Powered by

    Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service